| Platinum | Mercasa Little Italy Eatery |
| Gold | Maria's Pizza West |
| Silver | Speekezzies Cafe & Wine Bar |
| Bronze | Al Dente |
| Bronze | Maria's Original Pizza |
| Top Pick | East Side Mario's Brantford |
| Top Pick | La Bottega - Italian Fine Foods & Delicatessan |
| Top Pick | Luciani's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pace's Take Out & Catering |
| Top Pick | Papa John's Pizza |