| Platinum | Maria's Pizza West |
| Gold | Maria's Original Pizza |
| Silver | Luciani's Pizza |
| Bronze | Mercasa Little Italy Eatery |
| Top Pick | From Scratch Cafe Bistro |
| Top Pick | Gigi's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mariano's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizza-Roma |
| Top Pick | Stromboli's Brick Oven Pizza |
| Top Pick | Zaza's Pizzeria Inc |
| Gillies Take-out | |
| Papa John's Pizza |