| Platinum | Sugar & Spice Bakery |
| Gold | Cake and Crumb |
| Silver | Bun Shoppe Bakery |
| Bronze | Joosie Sweets Donuts |
| Bronze | The Windmill Country Market |
| Top Pick | Cobs Bakery |
| Top Pick | Lidz Cinnabunz |
| Top Pick | Little Paris Bread Co. |
| Top Pick | Mercasa Little Italy Eatery |
| Top Pick | No Mooin' Around |
| Top Pick | Sweet Bakery |
| AP Bakery | |
| The Cocoa Bomb |